Having faced off against this card several times already, it takes a lot to defend against a board with Tifa, Martial Artist on the field, having devastating potential with the right firepower to back her up
Fairly niche card, even when you play with it you usually don't want to have to find it and play it, but as it is the best at doing what it does it has retained its main cube slot
Despite requiring 8 mana upfront, I still prefer Avacyn, Angel of Hope for mass indestructible, and also Eldrazi Monument if I'm running a Tokens and/or Sacrifice strategy
Sadly, the alternate mode of "kill a creature with converted mana cost 3 or less" is generally going to be better than the Charms options
However, before we name contenders, let's establish the key criteria that shape this iconic debate
Forcing your opponents' creatures to enter the battlefield tapped happens to shut down a lot of things, including any deck that is centered around using creatures with blitz